Matt McGee Recalls SEO’s Wild West Era

▼ Summary
– Matt McGee, former Editor-in-Chief at Search Engine Land, discussed the early “Wild West” days of SEO, which involved black hat tactics like keyword stuffing and cloaking.
– The interview covered SEO’s evolution, including a discussion on whether AI will eventually kill SEO.
– McGee began his career by self-teaching SEO in the late 90s, using early resources from Danny Sullivan.
– He founded a blog in 2004 to translate high-level SEO concepts for small business owners, which led to joining Search Engine Land.
– The conversation also touched on key search history eras like Panda and Penguin, and the unsung heroes of search who advocated for user-focused tactics.
Matt McGee, the former Editor-in-Chief at Search Engine Land and technically my boss at one point, recently sat down with me for a conversation that was equal parts nostalgia and forward-looking analysis. He vividly recalled the “Wild West” days of SEO, a time when keyword stuffing, cloaking, and other tactics now labeled as “black hat” were standard practice for ranking content. It was a chaotic, fun era, but the industry has transformed dramatically since then.
We also tackled the pressing question of whether AI will kill SEO, along with a deep dive into how search marketing has evolved over the decades. The interview covers a broad range of topics, from the late 90s discovery of search marketing to the modern challenges of AI-generated content.
Here is a breakdown of our discussion:
- Discovering search marketing in the late 90s, during the pre-Google era of Excite, AltaVista, and Northern Light.To learn more about Matt McGee, visit seosavvyagent.com.


