Tim Schafer Confirms No More Sequels for Brütal Legend or Psychonauts

▼ Summary
– Double Fine is releasing a new game called Keeper in October 2025, which is an atmospheric puzzle adventure about a lighthouse.
– Tim Schafer is working on multiple new projects at Double Fine, all of which are original IPs and not sequels.
– The studio has ruled out sequels like Psychonauts 3 or Brütal Legend 2 in the short to mid-term, focusing instead on original content.
– Microsoft’s acquisition provided Double Fine with resources, as seen in Psychonauts 2, but Keeper is described as smaller-scale.
– Keeper is led by Lee Petty, allowing Schafer to focus on other projects within the studio.
Double Fine Productions is gearing up for the October launch of its new atmospheric puzzle adventure, Keeper, while studio head Tim Schafer confirms the team is actively developing multiple original projects, none of which are sequels to beloved titles like Brütal Legend or Psychonauts. This strategic shift toward fresh intellectual property reflects the studio’s desire to explore new creative territory after the extensive development of Psychonauts 2.
During a recent interview, Schafer emphasized that the studio is currently focused on several original IPs, noting that the completion of Psychonauts 2 has satisfied the team’s appetite for sequels for the foreseeable future. While he stopped short of revealing specific details about these upcoming titles, his comments clearly indicate that fans should not expect a follow-up to Brütal Legend or a third Psychonauts game anytime soon.
The development of Psychonauts 2 was significantly influenced by Microsoft’s acquisition of Double Fine in 2019. According to Schafer, the financial backing from Microsoft allowed the team to reintroduce content that had previously been cut due to budget constraints, including additional boss fights. This support enabled the studio to deliver a more complete and polished experience upon the game’s release in 2021.
In contrast to the larger scale of Psychonauts 2, Keeper is described as a smaller project, though one that doesn’t compromise on quality. Helmed by Lee Petty, the game invites players to awaken a long-forgotten lighthouse and guide it on a mysterious journey. Set to release on October 17, 2025, for PC and Xbox Series X|S, Keeper represents the next step in Double Fine’s evolving creative direction.
While Schafer’s remarks don’t entirely rule out the possibility of returning to established franchises someday, his current focus remains firmly on original concepts. For now, Double Fine fans can look forward to uncharted experiences and innovative gameplay as the studio continues to build on its legacy of imaginative and genre-defining titles.
(Source: IGN)